Inconclusive sighting

Can you identify this sighting?

Unidentified at suppressed - 24 May 2022
Unidentified at suppressed - 24 May 2022
Unidentified at suppressed - 24 May 2022
Request use of media

Identification history

Comments from moderator

See comments
Insufficient or inconclusive evidence 24 Jul 2022 Tapirlord
Unidentified 24 May 2022 waltraud

Identify this sighting


Please Login or Register to identify this sighting.

User's notes

These climbers were dumped in the nature reserve. I would be grateful if someone can identify the species. Unfortunately, garden waste is regularly dumped east of the Fair residential estate (in addition to dumbed food and rubbish). i reported many times to land manager. FoMM and conservation council spent 150.000 to educate Fair residents inthe first years when residents moved in. However, The Fair with its frequent change of renting people is a catastrophe for the grassy woodland and its inhabitants east of the estate: dogs are exercised in the reserve, cats roam, pest birds are hand-fed by residents and have now taken over driving out the last remaining little woodland birds...

6 comments

Tapirlord wrote:
   24 May 2022
Sorry to hear that Waltraud, unfortunately I'm not going to be of much use here, Michael might have some clues.
   1 Jul 2022
Sorry Waltraud can't work this one out. it is an offence under teh Nature Conservation Act (with a maximum penalty of about $5,000) to take reproductive plant material into a reserve without a permit. It is also an offence with similar punishment to bring a pest plant into a reserve. I would advise that if you see some-one doing it take a photo (also of their car number plate if you can) don't directly confront perpetrator but report to the PCS compliance unit, There probably also are litter offences. Try and ensure that photo contains reproductive part of plant such as a flower or seed pod. You may have to photograph this after the dumper has left.
   1 Jul 2022
Humans, hey.
waltraud wrote:
   2 Jul 2022
The worst problem is a well-meaning guy who mows in the reserve backing his and neighbour's backyards at Rivett Street; he spreads the clippings containing Chilean Needle grass in the nature reserve. I told PCS many times and sent photos; I even asked a witness because it seems that the preference is to not believe me.
When I complain about lack of a management plan, lack of compliance management, rangers not seeing through 1 (one) season because of frequent change of staff, lack of PCS corporate knowledge, lack of knowledge of the history of a site I'm told off as being rude and disrespectful. This really hurts... I have enough. It looks to me as if the urban CNP reserves (except Mulligans Flat and Goorrooyaroo) are now administered for recreational purposes and considered a lost cause for conservation management.
   2 Jul 2022
Your last point is also my experience, with the majority of the conservation effort now undertaken by a small number of volunteers.
waltraud wrote:
   2 Jul 2022
I'd like to hear from more parkcare groups. Unfortunately, it seems to me that groups work harder and harder (2 ranger positions were culled, one north one south) and have hardly the time and energy or the will to reflect on the situation and express their concern to higher levels of management.
I started to think that is unethical of a Government and its PS to encourage volunteers to do the conservation management of urban reserves under current conditions, some of which I listed above, knowing full well the volunteers can't shoulder all work - it is unsustainable. Volunteers were always supposed to assist; we are not the land manager and we can't cooperate because there is hardly anyone to cooperate with (let alone the expertise input required).

Please Login or Register to comment.

Sighting information

  • 4 - 15 Abundance
  • 24 May 2022 04:07 PM Recorded on
  • waltraud Recorded by

Additional information

  • 1 metre to 5 metres Plant height

Record quality

  • Images or audio
  • More than one media file
  • Confirmed by an expert moderator
  • Nearby sighting(s) of same species
  • GPS evidence of location
  • Description
  • Additional attributes
2,152,973 sightings of 19,940 species in 6,475 locations from 11,410 contributors
CCA 3.0 | privacy
We acknowledge the Traditional Owners of this land and acknowledge their continuing connection to their culture. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present.