I think the deeply serrated submarginal dark line visible in photo#2, the straight forewing costa, and the recurved forewing margin, are unlike most Scopula.
Ok thank you! I took a complete guess based off looking through photos of other sightings since I haven't tried much moth ID before - what about Casbia sp?
Looking at http://v4.boldsystems.org/index.php/Taxbrowser_Taxonpage?searchMenu=taxonomy&query=boarmia&taxon=boarmia, I do not see any with a recurved forewing margin such as your specimen has. I think identifying it's species will be non-trivial.