Cacomantis flabelliformis

Fan-tailed Cuckoo at Bonython, ACT

Cacomantis flabelliformis at Bonython, ACT - 27 Feb 2023
Cacomantis flabelliformis at Bonython, ACT - 27 Feb 2023
Cacomantis flabelliformis at Bonython, ACT - 27 Feb 2023
Cacomantis flabelliformis at Bonython, ACT - 27 Feb 2023
Cacomantis flabelliformis at Bonython, ACT - 27 Feb 2023
Request use of media

Identification history

Cacomantis flabelliformis 12 Mar 2023 natureguy
Cacomantis flabelliformis 11 Mar 2023 Liam.m
Cacomantis variolosus 11 Mar 2023 MatthewFrawley
Eudynamys orientalis 27 Feb 2023 CarbonAI
Cacomantis variolosus 27 Feb 2023 RodDeb

Identify this sighting


Please Login or Register to identify this sighting.

User's notes

the pattern of the marking on the underparts and the dark eye with the lack of a yellow eye-ring show it is a Brush Cuckoo not a Fan-tailed Cuckoo - confirmed on eBird by moderator Kim after notifying us that it was an unusual sighting for this area so was treated as a rare sighting. Not the best pics but it was scared off by a Red Wattlebird a short time after these pics were taken. Also confirmed on ABID as a Brush Cuckoo.

5 comments

Liam.m wrote:
   11 Mar 2023
@natureguy, @LukeD
natureguy wrote:
   12 Mar 2023
Yes I agree, looks like a Fan-tailed to me, this bird is pretty dark plain brown whereas immature Brush has very buffy mottling and striping throughout the plumage. The eye-ring is also often indistinct or absent in immature birds so I see no reason to count that feature as conclusive either way, and again, the patterning on the underparts looks like Fan-tailed not Brush to me. Also given the fairly open habitat in an urban area it is more likely to be a Fan-tailed (though not 100% guaranteed), but combined with the other features I'm pretty convinced. It might help to have a look at some of the other images on CNM or eBird of both species immatures to see what I'm talking about if you're not convinced. e.g. this Fan-tailed, which has the typical brown underparts but no yellow eye-ring Cacomantis flabelliformis (Fan-tailed Cuckoo) , and this one of yours Cacomantis variolosus (Brush Cuckoo) which is a typical immature Brush with very buffy plumage.
   12 Mar 2023
Think this one, and at least one of the other examples you have given are open for debate on the correct identification.
Liam.m wrote:
   12 Mar 2023
I wholeheartedly agree with Luke on this. The bird pictured in this sighting is a much better fit for a young Fan-tailed than a young brush (for the reasons he has stated above). I saw a similar bird a few years ago, and was also told by the moderator at the time (not Kim) that it was a young brush, for the same reasons as she stated (i.e. lack of yellow eye ring and marking of underparts). This bird was also a young Fan-tailed (see ebird list https://ebird.org/australia/checklist/S27252978). Both the examples Luke has provided have been correctly identified. As he said, the eye-ring in young birds is often indistinct or absent, so it is not a good ID point. Moreover, the patterning in young Brush and Fan-tailed cuckoos differs quite noticeably, and though Fan-tailed can appear quite mottly, they lack the buffiness and more distinct barring present in young Brush cuckoos.
RodDeb wrote:
   12 Mar 2023
thanks all, wish we had got pics of it out in the open before the Red Wattlebird chased it off but it was too quick. Had a look at the ebird sighting given and could see a pale eye ring on that bird. So are on the fence could be one or the other, unfortunately the bird was not telling.

Please Login or Register to comment.

Nearby sightings

Page 1 of 1 - image sightings only

Junonia villida (Meadow Argus) at Stranger Pond - 10 Apr 2024 by RodDeb
Phylidonyris novaehollandiae (New Holland Honeyeater) at Stranger Pond - 10 Apr 2024 by RodDeb
Melithreptus lunatus (White-naped Honeyeater) at Stranger Pond - 10 Apr 2024 by RodDeb
Pelecanus conspicillatus (Australian Pelican) at Stranger Pond - 10 Apr 2024 by RodDeb
Ischnura heterosticta (Common Bluetail Damselfly) at Stranger Pond - 2 Mar 2024 by RodDeb
Poodytes gramineus (Little Grassbird) at Stranger Pond - 2 Mar 2024 by RodDeb
Acanthiza nana (Yellow Thornbill) at Stranger Pond - 9 Feb 2024 by RodDeb
Acrida conica (Giant green slantface) at Stranger Pond - 9 Feb 2024 by RodDeb
Nososticta solida (Orange Threadtail) at Stranger Pond - 9 Feb 2024 by RodDeb
Phalaenoides tristifica (Willow-herb Day-moth) at Stranger Pond - 21 Jan 2024 by RodDeb
Arsipoda sp. (genus) (A flea beetle) at Stranger Pond - 5 Dec 2023 by RodDeb
Nososticta solida (Orange Threadtail) at Stranger Pond - 18 Nov 2023 by RodDeb
Ocybadistes walkeri (Green Grass-dart) at Stranger Pond - 18 Nov 2023 by RodDeb
Ischnura heterosticta (Common Bluetail Damselfly) at BON200: Stranger Pond Bonython at BBQ shelter - 18 Nov 2023 by RodDeb
Ischnura heterosticta (Common Bluetail Damselfly) at Stranger Pond - 10 Nov 2023 by RodDeb
Dianella sp. (Flax Lily) at Stranger Pond - 10 Nov 2023 by RodDeb
Caligavis chrysops (Yellow-faced Honeyeater) at Stranger Pond - 10 Nov 2023 by RodDeb
Papilio aegeus (Orchard Swallowtail, Large Citrus Butterfly) at Stranger Pond - 10 Nov 2023 by RodDeb
Junonia villida (Meadow Argus) at Stranger Pond - 10 Nov 2023 by RodDeb
Pieris rapae (Cabbage White) at Bonython, ACT - 28 Oct 2023 by RodDeb
Ischnura heterosticta (Common Bluetail Damselfly) at Bonython, ACT - 28 Oct 2023 by RodDeb
Polistes (Polistella) humilis (Common Paper Wasp) at Bonython, ACT - 28 Oct 2023 by RodDeb
Rhipidura albiscapa (Grey Fantail) at Bonython, ACT - 28 Sep 2023 by RodDeb
Sericornis frontalis (White-browed Scrubwren) at Bonython, ACT - 28 Sep 2023 by RodDeb
Porphyrio melanotus (Australasian Swamphen) at Bonython, ACT - 28 Sep 2023 by RodDeb
Phalaenoides tristifica (Willow-herb Day-moth) at Bonython, ACT - 28 Sep 2023 by RodDeb
Anthochaera carunculata (Red Wattlebird) at Bonython, ACT - 3 Aug 2023 by RodDeb
Strepera graculina (Pied Currawong) at Bonython, ACT - 29 Jun 2023 by RodDeb
Phylidonyris novaehollandiae (New Holland Honeyeater) at Bonython, ACT - 29 Jun 2023 by RodDeb
Acanthiza reguloides (Buff-rumped Thornbill) at Bonython, ACT - 29 Jun 2023 by RodDeb
Corcorax melanorhamphos (White-winged Chough) at Bonython, ACT - 29 Jun 2023 by RodDeb
Phylidonyris novaehollandiae (New Holland Honeyeater) at Bonython, ACT - 10 May 2023 by RodDeb
Acanthorhynchus tenuirostris (Eastern Spinebill) at Bonython, ACT - 10 May 2023 by RodDeb
Pachycephala pectoralis (Golden Whistler) at Bonython, ACT - 10 May 2023 by RodDeb
Pardalotus punctatus (Spotted Pardalote) at Bonython, ACT - 22 Mar 2023 by RodDeb
Hemicordulia australiae (Australian Emerald) at Bonython, ACT - 27 Feb 2023 by RodDeb
Hemicordulia tau (Tau Emerald) at Bonython, ACT - 27 Feb 2023 by RodDeb
Ocybadistes walkeri (Green Grass-dart) at Bonython, ACT - 27 Feb 2023 by RodDeb
Vespula germanica (European wasp) at Bonython, ACT - 27 Feb 2023 by RodDeb
Nososticta solida (Orange Threadtail) at Bonython, ACT - 27 Feb 2023 by RodDeb
Junonia villida (Meadow Argus) at Bonython, ACT - 27 Feb 2023 by RodDeb
Phalaenoides tristifica (Willow-herb Day-moth) at Bonython, ACT - 7 Feb 2023 by RodDeb
Ocybadistes walkeri (Green Grass-dart) at Bonython, ACT - 7 Feb 2023 by RodDeb
Orthetrum caledonicum (Blue Skimmer) at Bonython, ACT - 7 Feb 2023 by RodDeb
Chironomidae (family) (Non-biting Midge) at Bonython, ACT - 15 Oct 2022 by RodDeb
Spilopelia chinensis (Spotted Dove) at Bonython, ACT - 15 Oct 2022 by RodDeb
Spilopelia chinensis (Spotted Dove) at Bonython, ACT - 4 Jun 2022 by RodDeb
Phylidonyris novaehollandiae (New Holland Honeyeater) at Bonython, ACT - 4 Jun 2022 by RodDeb
Psephotus haematonotus (Red-rumped Parrot) at Bonython, ACT - 4 Jun 2022 by RodDeb
Anhinga novaehollandiae (Australasian Darter) at Bonython, ACT - 4 Jun 2022 by RodDeb
Perca fluviatilis (Redfin) at Bonython, ACT - 24 Apr 2022 by RodDeb
Iridomyrmex purpureus (Meat Ant) at Bonython, ACT - 9 Apr 2022 by RodDeb
Phylidonyris novaehollandiae (New Holland Honeyeater) at Bonython, ACT - 27 Mar 2022 by RodDeb
Oenothera stricta subsp. stricta (Common Evening Primrose) at Bonython, ACT - 27 Mar 2022 by RodDeb
Orthetrum caledonicum (Blue Skimmer) at Bonython, ACT - 27 Mar 2022 by RodDeb
Chauliognathus tricolor (Tricolor soldier beetle) at Bonython, ACT - 13 Mar 2022 by RodDeb
Cisticola exilis (Golden-headed Cisticola) at Bonython, ACT - 18 Feb 2022 by RodDeb
Idalima affinis (A day flying moth) at Bonython, ACT - 11 Feb 2022 by WarrenRowland
Malurus cyaneus (Superb Fairywren) at Bonython, ACT - 11 Feb 2022 by WarrenRowland
Hemicordulia tau (Tau Emerald) at Bonython, ACT - 31 Dec 2021 by RodDeb
Melithreptus lunatus (White-naped Honeyeater) at Bonython, ACT - 25 Nov 2021 by RodDeb
Caligavis chrysops (Yellow-faced Honeyeater) at Bonython, ACT - 25 Nov 2021 by RodDeb
Acrocephalus australis (Australian Reed-Warbler) at Bonython, ACT - 25 Nov 2021 by RodDeb
Phylidonyris novaehollandiae (New Holland Honeyeater) at Bonython, ACT - 8 Aug 2021 by RodDeb
Falco cenchroides (Nankeen Kestrel) at Bonython, ACT - 3 Jul 2021 by RodDeb
Spilopelia chinensis (Spotted Dove) at Bonython, ACT - 23 May 2021 by RodDeb
Heteronympha merope (Common Brown Butterfly) at Bonython, ACT - 2 Apr 2021 by RodDeb
Hemicordulia tau (Tau Emerald) at Bonython, ACT - 2 Apr 2021 by RodDeb
Iridomyrmex purpureus (Meat Ant) at Bonython, ACT - 14 Feb 2021 by RodDeb
Camponotus aeneopilosus (A Golden-tailed sugar ant) at Bonython, ACT - 14 Feb 2021 by RodDeb
Junonia villida (Meadow Argus) at Bonython, ACT - 17 Jan 2021 by RodDeb
Sphex sp. (genus) (Unidentified Sphex digger wasp) at Bonython, ACT - 17 Jan 2021 by RodDeb
Ischnura heterosticta (Common Bluetail Damselfly) at Bonython, ACT - 8 Nov 2020 by RodDeb
Spilopelia chinensis (Spotted Dove) at Bonython, ACT - 2 Sep 2020 by RodDeb
Philemon corniculatus (Noisy Friarbird) at Bonython, ACT - 3 Jan 2020 by RodDeb
Hemicordulia tau (Tau Emerald) at Bonython, ACT - 6 Oct 2019 by RodDeb
Ptilotula penicillata (White-plumed Honeyeater) at Bonython, ACT - 6 Oct 2019 by RodDeb
Sceliphron laetum (Common mud dauber wasp) at Bonython, ACT - 28 Jan 2019 by RodDeb
Aythya australis (Hardhead) at Bonython, ACT - 28 Jan 2019 by RodDeb
Psephotus haematonotus (Red-rumped Parrot) at Bonython, ACT - 28 Jan 2019 by RodDeb
Porphyrio melanotus (Australasian Swamphen) at Bonython, ACT - 28 Jan 2019 by RodDeb
Sceliphron laetum (Common mud dauber wasp) at Bonython, ACT - 6 Jan 2019 by WarrenRowland
Malurus cyaneus (Superb Fairywren) at Bonython, ACT - 31 Dec 2018 by WarrenRowland
Acacia boormanii (Snowy River Wattle) at Bonython, ACT - 24 Sep 2016 by michaelb
Bidens pilosa (Cobbler's Pegs, Farmer's Friend) at Bonython, ACT - 9 Apr 2016 by michaelb
Cygnus atratus (Black Swan) at Bonython, ACT - 26 Dec 2015 by michaelb
Grevillea sp. (Grevillea) at Bonython, ACT - 12 Oct 2015 by michaelb
Eucalyptus sideroxylon (Mugga Ironbark) at Bonython, ACT - 5 Jul 2015 by michaelb
Banksia ericifolia subsp. ericifolia (Heath-leaved Banksia) at Bonython, ACT - 21 Jun 2015 by michaelb

Location information

Sighting information

  • 1 Abundance
  • 27 Feb 2023 12:30 PM Recorded on
  • RodDeb Recorded by

Species information

Record quality

  • Images or audio
  • More than one media file
  • Confirmed by an expert moderator
  • Nearby sighting(s) of same species
  • GPS evidence of location
  • Description
  • Additional attributes
2,166,803 sightings of 20,587 species in 6,785 locations from 11,950 contributors
CCA 3.0 | privacy
We acknowledge the Traditional Owners of this land and acknowledge their continuing connection to their culture. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present.