Sisyromyia sp. (genus)

1 A bee fly at Paddys River, ACT

Sisyromyia sp. (genus) at Paddys River, ACT - 7 Nov 2019
Sisyromyia sp. (genus) at Paddys River, ACT - 7 Nov 2019
Request use of media

Identification history

Sisyromyia sp. (genus) 8 Nov 2019 MichaelMulvaney
Sisyromyia sp. (genus) 7 Nov 2019 jgl
Bombyliidae (family) 7 Nov 2019 DPRees125

Identify this sighting


Please Login or Register to identify this sighting.

5 comments

DPRees125 wrote:
   8 Nov 2019
I think we can go further, had a look at what is on ALA and it seems to me that a good match for this specimen is a member of the genus Sisyromyia
jgl wrote:
   8 Nov 2019
I've asked Xuankun Li, one of the world experts on this group, and Sisyromyia happens to be correct (he thinks Sisyromyia thomsoni based on the location). However, I'd be disinclined to confirm this ID based on ALA alone as there's a lot of unreliable image ID's on there...

For example, search for 'Bombyliinae' on ALA. Look under the 'Classification' tab - you'll see the genus 'Bombylius Linnaeus, 1758'. Click on this genus and open the gallery - you'll see an image under 'Types', and 6 images under 'Images', the first (from the left) of which shows a Formosia (Euamphibolia) nr. speciosa (actually in family Tachinidae). The next 3 images show 3 different bombyliids, none of which are Bombylius (present day definition); in fact Bombylius is a European and North American genus which is not known to be present in Australia. The last two images were taken in Canada and I've no idea if they're correctly ID'd.

I'm just making a point that you have to be very careful when making genus ID's based on browsing ALA - sometimes its extremely helpful and can send you in the right direction (to find a more reliable source), but you should always be wary of non-type image ID's which have been aggregated from the Flickr (or similar sites) of private individuals.

Cheers
DPRees125 wrote:
   8 Nov 2019
So you have asked an authority on these flies and he thinks that is a reasonable answer and then you say that ALA is unreliable (which it may well be) and somehow the view of that person, who may have extra info and experience available to them, is questionable, interesting logic....
jgl wrote:
   8 Nov 2019
My apologies, that was poorly phrased, what I meant is:

- I've asked Xuankun Li, one of the world experts on this group, what he thinks this specimen is.

- He asked the location of the sighting, and when I told him ACT, he said Sisyromyia thomsoni.

- Now, in the event that i had not been able to get in contact with Dr Li and ask his opinion, then I wouldn't have been confident enough to confirm that this observation was Sisyromyia, based solely on the images shown on the 'Sisyromyia' ALA galley, especially given that there are no 'Type' images available there.

- World experts can be hard to pin down every time something like this comes up, and I'm not saying we need to consult one each time, but I simply wanted to draw attention to the fact that ALA can be unreliable, and is risky to use as a sole authority, especially without 'Type' images.

Does this make more sense?
DPRees125 wrote:
   8 Nov 2019
Yes, I am more than aware of the lack of experts in this space and that ALA contains questionable material. One does wonder what its host (CSIRO) does about cleaning it up? Thank you for your trouble to date.

Please Login or Register to comment.

Nearby sightings

Page 1 of 1 - image sightings only

Acruroperla atra (A stonefly) at Tharwa, ACT - 6 Nov 2024 by DPRees125
Dichromodes confluaria (Ceremonial Heath Moth) at Tharwa, ACT - 5 Nov 2024 by RAllen
Ozothamnus rosmarinifolius (Rosemary Everlasting) at Tharwa, ACT - 30 Aug 2024 by nathkay
Armillaria sp. (A honey fungus) at Namadgi National Park - 4 May 2024 by HelenCross
Utetheisa pulchelloides (Heliotrope Moth) at Namadgi National Park - 9 Mar 2024 by RAllen
Eulamprus tympanum (Southern Water Skink) at Gibraltar Pines - 28 Feb 2024 by KorinneM
Acritoscincus duperreyi (Eastern Three-lined Skink) at Gibraltar Pines - 28 Feb 2024 by KorinneM
Austroaeschna parvistigma (Swamp Darner) at Tharwa, ACT - 28 Feb 2024 by KorinneM
Chrysolarentia conifasciata (Broad-banded Carpet) at Gibraltar Pines - 16 Jan 2024 by Christine
Synthemis eustalacta (Swamp Tigertail) at Gibraltar Pines - 6 Jan 2024 by Christine
Zizina otis (Common Grass-Blue) at Gibraltar Pines - 6 Jan 2024 by Christine
Vanessa itea (Yellow Admiral) at Gibraltar Pines - 6 Jan 2024 by Christine
Neolucia hobartensis (Montane Heath-blue) at Gibraltar Pines - 6 Jan 2024 by RAllen
Vanessa kershawi (Australian Painted Lady) at Gibraltar Pines - 6 Jan 2024 by Christine
Senecio campylocarpus (Swamp Cotton Fireweed) at Gibraltar Pines - 31 Dec 2023 by Tapirlord
Heteronympha cordace (Bright-eyed Brown) at Namadgi National Park - 11 Dec 2023 by JohnBundock
Vanessa itea (Yellow Admiral) at Gibraltar Pines - 10 Nov 2023 by SWishart
Zizina otis (Common Grass-Blue) at Gibraltar Pines - 10 Nov 2023 by SWishart
Geranium neglectum (Red-stemmed Cranesbill) at Paddys River, ACT - 27 Apr 2023 by JohnBundock
Coracina novaehollandiae (Black-faced Cuckooshrike) at Paddys River, ACT - 27 Jan 2023 by MatthewFrawley
Arthropodium milleflorum (Vanilla Lily) at Paddys River, ACT - 27 Jan 2023 by MatthewFrawley
Plebs bradleyi (Enamelled spider) at Paddys River, ACT - 27 Jan 2023 by MatthewFrawley
Comesperma retusum (Mountain Milkwort) at Paddys River, ACT - 3 Jan 2023 by RAllen
Myosotis laxa subsp. caespitosa (Water Forget-me-not) at Paddys River, ACT - 3 Jan 2023 by RAllen
Synthemis eustalacta (Swamp Tigertail) at Paddys River, ACT - 29 Dec 2022 by KorinneM
Phalaenoides tristifica (Willow-herb Day-moth) at Paddys River, ACT - 27 Dec 2022 by patrickcox
Epacris breviflora (Drumstick Heath) at Paddys River, ACT - 26 Dec 2022 by Ned_Johnston
Hakea microcarpa (Small-fruit Hakea) at Paddys River, ACT - 26 Dec 2022 by Ned_Johnston
Phalaenoides tristifica (Willow-herb Day-moth) at Paddys River, ACT - 11 Dec 2022 by MatthewFrawley
Geranomyia sp. (genus) (A limoniid crane fly) at Paddys River, ACT - 10 Dec 2022 by MatthewFrawley
Olearia erubescens (Silky Daisybush) at Paddys River, ACT - 10 Dec 2022 by MatthewFrawley
Austrolestes leda (Wandering Ringtail) at Paddys River, ACT - 10 Dec 2022 by MatthewFrawley
Epacris breviflora (Drumstick Heath) at Paddys River, ACT - 10 Dec 2022 by MatthewFrawley
Griseargiolestes intermedius (Alpine Flatwing) at Paddys River, ACT - 10 Dec 2022 by MatthewFrawley
Heteronympha cordace (Bright-eyed Brown) at Paddys River, ACT - 9 Dec 2022 by owenh
Melitulias graphicata (Mask Carpet) at Paddys River, ACT - 19 Nov 2022 by RAllen
Hypoxis hygrometrica var. hygrometrica (Golden Weather-grass) at Paddys River, ACT - 19 Nov 2022 by RAllen
Backobourkia sp. (genus) (An orb weaver) at Paddys River, ACT - 20 Mar 2022 by JohnBundock
Heteronympha penelope (Shouldered Brown) at Paddys River, ACT - 20 Mar 2022 by JohnBundock
Geranium sp. (Geranium) at Paddys River, ACT - 22 Feb 2022 by Miranda
Eulamprus tympanum (Southern Water Skink) at Paddys River, ACT - 25 Jan 2022 by JohnBundock
Euloxia meandraria (Two-lined Euloxia) at Paddys River, ACT - 25 Jan 2022 by JohnBundock
Chrysolarentia correlata (Yellow Carpet) at Namadgi National Park - 24 Jan 2022 by JohnBundock
Juncus phaeanthus (Dark-flower Rush) at Paddys River, ACT - 17 Jan 2022 by JaneR
Schoenus apogon (Common Bog Sedge) at Paddys River, ACT - 3 Jan 2022 by MatthewFrawley
Heteronympha cordace (Bright-eyed Brown) at Paddys River, ACT - 3 Jan 2022 by MatthewFrawley
Ranunculus lappaceus (Australian Buttercup) at Paddys River, ACT - 3 Jan 2022 by MatthewFrawley
Hypoxis hygrometrica (Golden Weather-grass) at Paddys River, ACT - 3 Jan 2022 by MatthewFrawley
Heteronympha cordace (Bright-eyed Brown) at Paddys River, ACT - 22 Dec 2021 by CathB
Commius elegans (Cherry Ballart Shield Bug) at Paddys River, ACT - 27 Oct 2021 by RAllen
Ranunculus pimpinellifolius (Bog Buttercup) at Paddys River, ACT - 22 Oct 2021 by RAllen
Trigonidiidae (family) (Swordtail cricket) at Paddys River, ACT - 25 Apr 2021 by Ned_Johnston
Gahnia subaequiglumis (Bog Saw-sedge) at Paddys River, ACT - 25 Apr 2021 by Ned_Johnston
Hepialidae (family) (Unidentified Swift or Ghost Moth) at Paddys River, ACT - 24 Apr 2021 by Ned_Johnston
Tebenna micalis (Small Thistle Moth) at Paddys River, ACT - 8 Mar 2021 by melanoxylon
Goniaea australasiae (Gumleaf grasshopper) at Paddys River, ACT - 8 Mar 2021 by melanoxylon
Phasmatodea (order) (Unidentified stick insect) at Paddys River, ACT - 8 Mar 2021 by melanoxylon
Neosparassus patellatus (Tasmanian Badge Huntsman) at Paddys River, ACT - 8 Mar 2021 by melanoxylon
Heteronympha penelope (Shouldered Brown) at Paddys River, ACT - 8 Mar 2021 by melanoxylon
Anachloris subochraria (Golden Grass Carpet) at Paddys River, ACT - 8 Mar 2021 by melanoxylon
Coronidium sp. at Paddys River, ACT - 7 Mar 2021 by RAllen
Heteronympha penelope (Shouldered Brown) at Paddys River, ACT - 28 Feb 2021 by MatthewFrawley
Gynoplistia sp. (genus) (Crane fly) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Myosotis laxa subsp. caespitosa (Water Forget-me-not) at Gibraltar Pines - 23 Feb 2021 by trevorpreston
Gahnia subaequiglumis (Bog Saw-sedge) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Acripeza reticulata (Mountain Katydid) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Baloskion australe (Mountain Cordrush) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Chrysolarentia heliacaria (Heliacaria Carpet) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Arthropodium milleflorum (Vanilla Lily) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Eulamprus heatwolei (Yellow-bellied Water Skink) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Utricularia dichotoma (Fairy Aprons, Purple Bladderwort) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Geranium neglectum (Red-stemmed Cranesbill) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Plebs bradleyi (Enamelled spider) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Carex fascicularis (Tassel Sedge) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Centipeda cunninghamii (Common Sneezeweed) at Paddys River, ACT - 23 Feb 2021 by tpreston
Vanessa kershawi (Australian Painted Lady) at Paddys River, ACT - 25 Jan 2021 by MatthewFrawley
Baeckea utilis (Mountain Baeckea) at Paddys River, ACT - 25 Jan 2021 by MatthewFrawley
Nyctemera amicus (Senecio Moth, Magpie Moth, Cineraria Moth) at Paddys River, ACT - 25 Jan 2021 by MatthewFrawley
Exoneura sp. (genus) (A reed bee) at Paddys River, ACT - 25 Jan 2021 by MatthewFrawley
Heteronympha cordace (Bright-eyed Brown) at Paddys River, ACT - 25 Jan 2021 by MatthewFrawley
Hesthesis montana (A wasp mimic longhorn beetle) at Paddys River, ACT - 9 Dec 2020 by Harrisi
Colluricincla harmonica (Grey Shrikethrush) at Tharwa, ACT - 3 Nov 2020 by MB
Platybrachys vidua (Eye-patterned Gum Hopper) at Paddys River, ACT - 15 Nov 2019 by Marthijn
Synthemis eustalacta (Swamp Tigertail) at Paddys River, ACT - 24 Feb 2019 by MatthewFrawley
Hesperilla munionga (Alpine Sedge-Skipper) at Paddys River, ACT - 20 Feb 2019 by DPRees125
Synthemis eustalacta (Swamp Tigertail) at Paddys River, ACT - 8 Jan 2019 by MatthewFrawley
Heteronympha cordace (Bright-eyed Brown) at Paddys River, ACT - 8 Jan 2019 by MatthewFrawley

Location information

Sighting information

Additional information

  • 5mm to 12mm Animal size

Species information

Record quality

  • Images or audio
  • More than one media file
  • Verified by an expert moderator
  • Nearby sighting(s) of same species
  • GPS evidence of location
  • Description
  • Additional attributes
1,892,085 sightings of 21,012 species in 9,264 locations from 12,861 contributors
CCA 3.0 | privacy
We acknowledge the Traditional Owners of this land and acknowledge their continuing connection to their culture. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present.